Franklin County

Columbus Public Adjuster for Fire, Wind, Hail, and Appraisal Claims

Keathley Claims Consultants is a licensed Ohio public adjuster (License #1367111) for home and commercial property claims in Columbus and statewide, based in Wellington, Lorain County. KCC’s founder has been an adjuster since 2011 (15+ years in the industry). KCC is rated 4.8 from 57 Google reviews (as of November 2026) and has 1,000+ happy clients. Call (419) 504-1601.

Ohio Public Adjuster License #1367111

Keathley Claims Consultants holds Ohio public adjuster License #1367111 and provides policyholder-side public adjusting services under that license.

Based in Wellington, Ohio

KCC is based at 155 N Main Street in Wellington, Ohio and serves Columbus, Ohio and statewide Ohio property claim matters when the assignment fits.

Claim documentation and estimate review

We're not attorneys or a law firm. The work includes property claim documentation, estimate review, negotiation, and appraisal-related valuation support.

Local Claim Problems

Insurance Claims In Columbus Need More Than A Quick Adjuster Visit

Columbus and Central Ohio properties can face wind, hail, severe storms, fire, smoke, water intrusion, roof, siding, commercial, residential, and underpaid claim disputes where scope and pricing need careful review.

We help identify missing scope, pricing issues, code items, hidden damage, and documentation gaps before a low settlement becomes the number everyone is stuck fighting over.

For the statewide overview of when to hire an Ohio public adjuster, start there. For fee questions, see how much a public adjuster costs in Ohio.

Common Columbus Claim Types

  • Wind and hail damage
  • Fire and smoke claims
  • Appraisal and valuation disputes

Central Ohio

Hail Claim Help in Westerville, Worthington, and Nearby Central Ohio Suburbs

Central Ohio hail does not stop at the Columbus city line. Keathley Claims Consultants is a licensed Ohio public adjuster based in Wellington. We serve Central Ohio, including Westerville, Worthington, and nearby suburbs. This section only routes you. The town hail pages carry the claim detail.

Westerville hail claims

Westerville is in Franklin and Delaware Counties. Open the Westerville hail page first. If the same storm includes wind, open the Westerville wind and hail page as well. Keep the carrier estimate, photos, and any letters with the file.

Worthington, Ohio hail claims

Worthington, Ohio is in Franklin County. It is not Worthington, Minnesota. Open the Worthington, Ohio hail page first, and the Worthington, Ohio wind and hail page when wind is part of the loss. Keep the written estimate and any denial or payment letter with the photos.

Other nearby suburbs

Hail pages are already published for Dublin, Powell, Delaware, and Hilliard, and for Grove City, Reynoldsburg, Pickerington, Newark, and Lancaster. The Columbus hail page and the Columbus wind and hail page cover the city. When coverage is accepted and the dispute is the amount of loss, start with Columbus appraisal. Appraisers in that process are expected to be competent and unbiased.

The Ohio Department of Insurance says to document the loss with photos or video before removing debris, to consider reasonable temporary repairs to avoid further damage, and to keep copies of correspondence. The longer list is the evidence checklist.

A denied hail roof, or damage the carrier called cosmetic, goes to the hail roof denial steps and the denial patterns guide. This section does not explain those steps. A commercial property owner goes to the commercial property hail claim page. The department also says not to let a contractor negotiate or settle the claim. See public adjuster vs contractor.

We’re licensed Ohio public adjusters (License #1367111). We’re not attorneys or a law firm.

Central Ohio hail questions

Do you serve Westerville and Worthington, Ohio for hail claims?
Keathley Claims Consultants is a licensed Ohio public adjuster (License #1367111). We serve Central Ohio, including Westerville, Worthington, and nearby suburbs. Start with the town hail page and the claim evidence checklist, and keep the carrier estimate and any letters.
Is my roofer allowed to negotiate my hail claim in Ohio?
The Ohio Department of Insurance says not to give a contractor power of attorney or permit a contractor to negotiate or settle your insurance claim. Ohio Revised Code Chapter 3951 requires a certificate before a person is paid to adjust a property claim in this state, subject to the exceptions in that chapter. See public adjuster vs contractor.

Claim Help Available Near Columbus

These are the claim categories where early documentation and a policyholder-side estimate can make the biggest difference.

Tornado Damage

A tornado can take a roof plane, a wall, or a whole elevation and leave the rest of the house standing. The first insurance estimate often prices what is still attached and skips openings, soaked interiors, scattered contents, and the cost of living somewhere else during a rebuild. We’re not attorneys or a law firm. We inspect the damage, review the policy, document the scope, and communicate with the carrier when a tornado claim is underpaid, delayed, denied, or incomplete.

Learn More

Fire/Smoke Damage

A fire loss is more than visible burn damage. Smoke, soot, odor, contents damage, electrical concerns, HVAC contamination, cleanup, temporary repairs, and hidden damage can all become part of the claim. If the insurance estimate misses those issues, the policyholder may be left without enough to recover properly. Keathley Claims Consultants helps Ohio homeowners, landlords, business owners, and property owners document fire and smoke damage, review the insurance company's estimate, organize the claim file, and push back when a fire claim is underpaid, delayed, denied, or incomplete.

Learn More

Wind/Hail Damage

Wind and hail can damage a property in ways that are obvious, hidden, or easy for an insurance estimate to miss. Missing shingles, lifted shingles, bruised roofing, dented gutters, damaged siding, window damage, interior leaks, and storm-created openings can all affect the value of a property insurance claim. Keathley Claims Consultants helps Ohio policyholders document wind and hail damage, review insurance estimates, organize the claim file, and push back when a storm claim is underpaid, delayed, denied, or stuck in review.

Learn More

Wind Damage

Wind damage claims often turn into disputes over what the storm caused, what was pre-existing, and whether the insurance estimate includes the full repair scope. Missing shingles, lifted shingles, creased tabs, damaged siding, loose fascia, damaged gutters, storm-created openings, and interior water damage can all affect the value of the claim. Keathley Claims Consultants helps Ohio policyholders document wind damage, review carrier estimates, organize the claim file, and push back when a wind claim is underpaid, delayed, denied, or incomplete.

Learn More

Hail Damage

Hail damage is not always obvious from the ground, and a low insurance estimate can miss important roof, siding, gutter, window, soft metal, and interior issues. Hail can bruise shingles, damage granules, crack siding, dent gutters, affect vents and window wraps, and create disputes over whether damage is functional, cosmetic, old, or storm-related. Keathley Claims Consultants helps Ohio policyholders document hail damage and challenge incomplete, underpaid, delayed, or denied hail claims.

Learn More

Burst Pipe Damage

A burst pipe is a sudden release inside the plumbing system — a split supply line, a freeze break, a failed fitting. The water path is usually longer than the room where the plumber stood. Keathley Claims Consultants helps Ohio homeowners document that path, review the policy, and push back when the carrier prices an access hole and a dry-out while wet cavities, matching, and additional living expense are still open. We’re not attorneys or a law firm.

Learn More

Start Your Claim Process Now & Get Inspection Priority Today!